Bay Area Seismic Retrofit Shoring: Earthquake Preparation Solutions
- Joe Lazzaretti
- Jan 2
- 11 min read
Updated: Jan 2
Earthquakes pose a serious risk to the San Francisco Bay Area, with a 72% chance of a magnitude 6.7 or higher quake by 2044. Many buildings, especially those built before 1980, remain vulnerable due to outdated construction standards. Seismic retrofitting offers a proven way to strengthen structures, reducing damage and ensuring safety during earthquakes. Key methods include:
Foundation bolting: Anchors the building to its foundation.
Cripple wall bracing: Reinforces weak walls between the foundation and first floor.
Fluid viscous dampers: Absorb seismic energy in taller buildings.
Advanced shoring systems: Stabilize structures during retrofits in challenging urban areas.
Retrofitting is an investment that prevents repair costs ranging from $10,000 to $200,000 and ensures buildings remain habitable after a quake. Programs like the Earthquake Brace + Bolt offer grants to help homeowners cover costs. Cities like Berkeley and Fremont have even introduced mandatory ordinances to address high-risk structures.
If you own an older property in the Bay Area, now is the time to act. Schedule a seismic assessment, work with licensed contractors, and protect your home, family, and investment.
Core Principles of Seismic Retrofit Shoring
Structural Support Methods for Earthquake Protection
Seismic retrofit shoring strengthens structures by anchoring them to their foundations and reinforcing weak points that are prone to failure during earthquakes. For wood-frame houses, the most common issue is the failure of perimeter cripple walls under shear stress [5].
To address this, house bolting secures the wood frame to the concrete foundation using anchor bolts or metal plates. Meanwhile, cripple wall bracing reinforces plywood panels to create shear walls that resist lateral forces [5]. Additionally, hold-downs - steel brackets fastened with anchor bolts - help secure wall studs to the foundation, providing extra stability under extreme tension [5].
For taller buildings, fluid viscous dampers (FVDs) play a key role in reducing floor accelerations and drift ratios while quickly dissipating seismic vibrations [4]. Engineers also focus on retrofitting critical structural joints, such as beam-to-column connections and column splices, to prevent brittle failures. In some cases, heavy exterior cladding is replaced with lighter curtain wall systems to lower the seismic load [4]. These upgrades are carefully designed to meet the specific building codes of the Bay Area.
Bay Area Building Code Requirements
Retrofitting strategies are tailored to comply with local building codes that address the Bay Area's unique seismic risks. For residential projects, Standard Plan A is commonly used. This plan applies a base shear coefficient of V = 0.186W, where W represents the building's weight [3]. This coefficient is slightly higher than the V = 0.17W requirement for new single-story construction under the California Building Code [3].
Older and historic buildings benefit from some regulatory flexibility. According to the International Existing Building Code (IEBC) and the California Historic Building Code, the seismic forces required for retrofitting are capped at 0.75 times the forces needed for new construction [3]. This adjustment balances the challenges of upgrading older structures with the goal of improving safety.
"The details and prescriptive provisions herein (the building code) are not intended to be the only acceptable strengthening methods permitted. Alternative details and methods may be used where approved by the code official."International Existing Building Code (Section A301.3) [3]
In response to the region's high seismic activity, several Bay Area cities have introduced mandatory retrofit ordinances targeting high-risk buildings. For example, cities like Berkeley and Fremont require seismic upgrades for unreinforced masonry (URM) and soft-story buildings [7][8]. Some jurisdictions, such as Fremont, offer incentives like waiving plan check and permit fees for projects that start within specific timelines [8]. Berkeley goes a step further by providing grants of up to $3,000 for seismic retrofits, with full cost coverage available for income-qualified residents [7].
Modern Seismic Shoring Techniques and Equipment
Shoring Systems for Retrofit Projects
Seismic retrofit shoring systems are specifically designed to address the unique challenges of the Bay Area's complex urban geology. For example, soldier beams with wood lagging are often used to provide lateral support during deep excavations. In tight urban spaces near transit corridors, tiebacks and internal bracing stabilize structures effectively. For deeper excavations - up to 68 feet - techniques like slant-drill underpinning combined with jet-grout cut-off walls are employed to maintain stability in dense urban areas like downtown San Francisco and Oakland [9].
Given the Bay Area's variable soil conditions, additional reinforcement methods are frequently necessary. Local permeation grouting is a go-to solution for strengthening weak soils during retrofit excavation work. On steep hillsides, where traditional shoring methods might not work, permanent soil nail walls offer a reliable alternative for long-term stability. In regions at risk for liquefaction, engineers often use soil-cement mix cut-off shoring, which creates barriers to prevent ground movement during earthquakes [9].
For residential retrofits, the Flush Cut Method has become a favored approach for building strong shear walls. This method involves trimming mudsills flush with studs using specialized saws, allowing plywood to be securely nailed to the foundation. The result closely mirrors the shear walls tested by the American Plywood Association [10]. Another option is the Stapled Blocking Method, which uses precision staple guns to avoid wood splitting - a common issue with traditional nails. Impressively, each staple provides the strength of about 80 nails [10].
These physical techniques lay the groundwork for the advanced technologies that enhance retrofit planning and execution.
Technology and Tools for Seismic Retrofitting
In addition to physical methods, cutting-edge software and tools are transforming how seismic retrofits are designed and implemented. For instance, the OpenSees framework enables engineers to conduct 3D nonlinear dynamic analyses, offering detailed insights into how buildings might perform during earthquakes. A notable application of this tool occurred in December 2015, when researchers Jiun-Wei Lai, Shanshan Wang, Matthew J. Schoettler, and Stephen A. Mahin evaluated a 35-story steel building in San Francisco, originally built in 1968. Their analysis revealed weak-story regions and brittle column splice failures - issues that traditional assessment methods might have missed [4].
For anchor design and installation, contractors turn to software like Hilti PROFIS, ensuring that expansion anchors meet precise seismic and concrete load requirements. This is especially critical for older structures, where concrete strength can vary and historical building codes (some dating as far back as 1927) must be taken into account [11]. Tools like AutoCAD and Revit are also indispensable, helping teams coordinate complex projects that involve simultaneous demolition and shoring [9].
On the hardware side, Triple Pendulum™ isolators have emerged as a game-changer for large commercial and institutional buildings. These devices significantly reduce earthquake damage - limiting repair costs to less than 2% of a building's replacement value - while maintaining both stiffness and damping, even in extreme conditions as cold as -54°F [6].
Bay Area Seismic Retrofit Case Studies
Commercial Building Retrofit Projects
One Maritime Plaza in San Francisco serves as a prime example of how seismic upgrades can be carried out in fully occupied buildings. This 28-story steel-framed office tower underwent retrofitting in 2004 under the guidance of SmithGroupJJR for Equity Office Properties. The retrofit included adding braces to the building's bottom story and installing new horizontal box beams at the brace intersections. These upgrades brought the structure up to "collapse prevention" standards for Maximum Considered Earthquake ground shaking, all while tenants continued their daily work without disruption [13].
Fox Plaza Tower, a 30-story mixed-use building, completed its seismic retrofit in March 2019. The project, led by Dr. Matt Skokan and General Contractor Plant Construction Company, addressed critical vulnerabilities, including haunched steel connections and high collapse risks. The solution involved installing 14 fluid viscous dampers across the first seven floors to dissipate seismic energy without overloading the foundation. Additionally, reinforcing ribs were welded to connections on floors 17-21. Before implementation, the design underwent rigorous full-scale testing at UC San Diego. Construction was carefully planned to minimize disruption, with less than 5% of residents affected at any time, and work inside individual units limited to just 2-3 days [14].
The Bayshore Viaduct retrofit, completed between 2000 and 2001, tackled unique infrastructure challenges. Limited overhead clearance beneath the viaduct required contractors to use an APE-8 pile driving hammer (24,000 foot-pounds) to install pipe piles in segments, welding each piece as it was driven into the ground. These new piles were then integrated into enlarged pile caps to handle earthquake-induced uplift forces, ensuring the viaduct could endure significant seismic events. These projects highlight the importance of customized engineering solutions to meet the Bay Area's seismic safety needs [12].
Residential Retrofits in High-Risk Zones
In the wake of the 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake, San Francisco implemented a mandatory soft-story retrofit program targeting 4,921 vulnerable buildings - structures with open ground floors, like garages, that are especially prone to collapse. By early 2024, 98% of property owners had applied for permits, and 65% of these retrofits were completed. Costs for these upgrades range from $60,000 to $1 million, depending on the building's size and complexity [2].
The 2014 South Napa earthquake provided clear evidence of the value of retrofitting. Homes that had undergone "brace and bolt" retrofitting - securing the structure to its foundation and reinforcing cripple walls - remained stable, while nearby non-retrofitted houses shifted off their foundations and were red-tagged as unsafe. Programs like the Earthquake Brace + Bolt program further support these efforts by offering grants of up to $3,000 to eligible homeowners in high-risk ZIP codes, making these essential upgrades more accessible beyond municipal initiatives [1].
Planning and Executing Seismic Retrofit Projects
Performing a Seismic Structural Assessment
Once you've explored seismic risks and modern shoring techniques, the next logical step is a detailed structural assessment. This process begins with identifying a building's specific vulnerabilities. For residential properties, this might include features like raised foundations, post-and-pier supports, hillside construction, or soft-story designs[1]. Older buildings often require extra scrutiny since many were constructed before updated seismic codes were in place. The assessment zeroes in on critical weak points, such as poorly secured frame-to-foundation connections that could allow the building to slide during an earthquake, or unbraced cripple walls in crawl spaces that might collapse under lateral forces[1].
For larger or more complex structures, engineers perform a base shear calculation. This measures the total force in pounds that the building must withstand during an earthquake, factoring in its weight and the expected ground acceleration for its Bay Area location[3]. These calculations are crucial in determining the strength requirements for the retrofit design. While simpler wood-frame homes may qualify for streamlined standards like "Standard Plan A" or "FEMA P-1100", more intricate setups - such as hillside homes, properties with basements, or those with rooms over garages - typically need custom-engineered designs prepared by licensed structural or civil engineers[1]. Considering the 72% likelihood of a magnitude 6.7 or greater earthquake hitting the Bay Area by 2044, these assessments are not just precautionary - they can save property owners anywhere from $10,000 to $200,000 in potential future repair costs[1].
Working with Specialized Contractors
Once you've identified your building's vulnerabilities, the next step is finding a contractor skilled in seismic retrofitting. After the structural assessment, choosing the right contractor becomes essential. Check their credentials with the California State License Board (CSLB) and prioritize those with specific training in seismic retrofitting, such as contractors listed in the Earthquake Brace + Bolt (EBB) program directory[1]. It's a good idea to get bids from at least three contractors and confirm that each has proper workers' compensation insurance and bonding[1].
Experienced contractors often take charge of the administrative aspects of the project. They handle everything from securing building permits and submitting structural plans to managing site documentation and applying for grant programs like EBB, which offers up to $3,000 in grants for eligible homeowners in high-risk ZIP codes[1]. For standard retrofits on raised foundations, costs typically range between $3,000 and $7,000, with projects usually completed in just a few days[1]. More complex retrofits, such as those for hillside properties or soft-story reinforcements, may require a higher investment but provide significantly greater protection.
The most reliable contractors focus on the Bay Area's specific seismic challenges rather than relying on generic national standards. They use high-quality hardware from trusted manufacturers like Simpson Strong-Tie and collaborate closely with structural engineers when custom solutions are needed[3]. Their expertise ensures that the retrofit is designed to meet local seismic demands, providing the best possible protection for your property.
How to Seismic Retrofit a House - Shear Wall Overturning Forces
Conclusion: Safer Buildings Through Seismic Retrofitting
Strengthening buildings against earthquakes isn’t just about meeting code requirements - it’s about protecting lives and investments. Modern shoring techniques, like foundation bolting, cripple wall bracing, and fluid viscous dampers, transform structural weaknesses into solid defenses. For homeowners, retrofitting can mean avoiding hefty repair bills after a major quake, while offering peace of mind through enhanced safety measures for residential properties[1].
Since the 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake, property owners and municipalities in the Bay Area have collectively invested $1.2 billion in seismic retrofits[2]. These efforts have undoubtedly improved the region’s resilience, but many older buildings still lack sufficient protection. Taking proactive steps not only ensures compliance with local codes but also safeguards your property and the people who rely on it.
"Spending a smaller amount of money to help reduce damage and help give your house earthquake resistance may be more beneficial than facing a much larger repair bill after an earthquake." - California Residential Mitigation Program[1]
Golden Gate Shoring specializes in seismic retrofit shoring, structural engineering, and foundation design, tailored to the Bay Area’s unique geological conditions. Whether it’s hillside homes or soft-story buildings, our team provides solutions that meet strict code standards while minimizing disruptions to your daily life.
Don’t wait until it’s too late. Contact Golden Gate Shoring today to schedule your seismic assessment and take the first step in protecting your property, your investment, and the people who depend on its safety.
FAQs
What are the best seismic retrofitting methods for older buildings in the Bay Area?
The best ways to retrofit older Bay Area buildings for earthquakes focus on making the structure more stable and better connected to its foundation. Key upgrades include strengthening the bond between walls and the foundation with anchor bolts or steel plates and reinforcing vulnerable areas like soft-story levels. To improve a building's ability to handle seismic forces, adding shear walls, cripple-wall bracing, or steel-frame panels is highly effective.
For older structures with unreinforced masonry or outdated commercial façades, steel-reinforced jackets or concrete shear walls can help prevent collapses. In higher-budget projects, base isolation systems may also be installed. These systems allow the building to move more freely during an earthquake, reducing the impact of ground motion. These retrofitting techniques have consistently shown their ability to minimize earthquake damage, making them crucial for safeguarding older buildings in the Bay Area's earthquake-prone landscape.
What are fluid viscous dampers, and how do they protect tall buildings during earthquakes?
Fluid viscous dampers are hydraulic tools specifically designed to lessen earthquake damage by absorbing and dispersing seismic energy. These devices work by generating resistance proportional to the speed of motion, transforming the earthquake's energy into heat. This process helps reduce a building's movement during seismic events.
In tall buildings, these dampers function as energy absorbers, limiting the motion that reaches the structural framework. This not only minimizes deformation but also protects non-structural components and reduces the likelihood of severe damage. Additionally, by cutting down the forces transmitted to the foundation, they lower repair expenses and downtime after an earthquake. This makes them an essential feature for enhancing the earthquake resistance of high-rise buildings.
What financial aid is available for Bay Area homeowners to help with seismic retrofits?
Homeowners in the Bay Area might be eligible for financial help through initiatives like the California Residential Mitigation Program (CRMP). This includes grants such as Earthquake Brace + Bolt (EBB) and Earthquake Soft-Story (ESS), offering between $3,000 and $13,000 to cover retrofit expenses. There may also be additional funding options for those who meet income requirements.
Some cities in the region provide further assistance, including tax credits, low-interest loans, or other grants specifically aimed at seismic safety improvements. It's worth checking with your local city or county offices to learn about programs available in your area.
Comments